Analysis
Overview
The aim of this task is to identify irregular uses of Properties Library that could be either frequent or hard to find. An example of irregular use is :
public RwProp<Integer> fish() {
return getBean().makeValueProp("fish", Integer.class, complextMethodToComputeFish());
} because the third argument must be a constant.
Task requirements
- Write a list with irregular uses - at least 3
- Add some checks or asserts to protect from irregular uses
- Make tests, which identify irregular uses.
Task result
The result of this task should be source code
Implementation idea
Prolib is a complex library. It is easy to use it irregular . It is hard to find the irregular uses, so it must have lots of conversations between teams. There is some ways to protect from irregular uses :
- using a compilator
- using exceptions
Related
How to demo
Explain the misuses to the team
Design
- Irregular pro lib uses:
- create method of resource property should not be dependent on any property except for final properties and resource properties.
- value properties that are initialized at their invocation - for example:
public RwProp<String> text() { return getBean().makeValueProp("text", String.class, "this is a string."); }
- should be initialized with ONLY the following:
- constant primitive types or literals.
- public static final things.
- should not set their value by a complex code invocation:
public RwProp<Integer> fish() { return getBean().makeValueProp("fish", Integer.class, complextMethodToComputeFish()); }
- should not create new objects.
public RwProp<Dummy> dummy() { return getBean().makeValueProp("dummy", Dummy.class, new Dummy()); }
- should be initialized with ONLY the following:
- properties of objects that are alike properties of other objects should create the former instead of returning them directly:
class Dummy extends BaseProObject{ public RwProp<String> text() { return getBean().makeValueProp("text", String.class, new String("this is a string.")); } } class DummyDependent extends BaseProObject{ public DummyDependent(Dummy dummy) { dummy().set(dummy); } public RwProp<Dummy> dummy() { return getBean().makeValueProp("dummy", Dummy.class); } //THIS SHOULD NOT BE POSSIBLE public RwProp<String> textOfDummy() { return dummy().get().text(); } }
- Misuse detection shall be done through checks and exception throwing.
- create method of resource property should not be dependent on any property except for final properties - the check should be made on ResourceProperty creation. It appears that the code is commented. It should be un-commented and things should be fixed and refactored.
- value properties that are initialized at their invocation - things should be checked and exception thrown:
- should check that the value is the same every time the property is got.
- should check that on initializing of the property, nothing else is read.
- properties of objects that are alike properties of other objects should create the former instead of returning them directly - should check in ProObject's methods that return properties that they construct new ones instead of reusing others. The check should be done at creation.
- A unit test for the 3 types of irregular use will be written.
Implementation
- done according to design - one more improper use imeplemented since it is part of another task but it is still an improper usage. See unit test for more information.
- a unit test for the misuse detection - PropertyMisuseDetection
- chages:
Testing
Comments
(Write comments for this or later revisions here.)